By Brittney Holden | Transportation Advisors
Why a driver’s annual review sometimes takes three emails and a call to the owner.
There’s an accident on a driver’s motor vehicle record (MVR), and nobody at the company has signed off on it. That’s usually what’s behind my call when I phone an owner about an annual review.
I start with a regular check-in. I ask how things are going, and then I get straight to it. We’ve been trying for three weeks to get a signed annual review back. There’s something on the driver’s record I want the company to look at, and we still don’t have the form. Sometimes our emails go unanswered. Sometimes we’ve heard back and are still waiting on the signed copy. Either way, the owner needs to know what’s outstanding and how much time is left to take care of it.
Why we start in month eleven
At Transportation Advisors, we start our clients’ annual driving record reviews in the eleventh month. That timing is intentional. If we pull an MVR and something on it needs the operator’s attention, I want the company to have time to look into it. I also know how long it can take to get a form back. If we waited until the review was nearly due to make the first request, there wouldn’t be much room for a second conversation, let alone a third.
For carriers subject to 49 CFR § 391.25, the federal requirement is to obtain and review each driver’s MVR at least once every 12 months. That means a record from every state where the driver held a license or permit during the past 12 months, not just the state on their current license. The carrier considers the driver’s accidents and violations in deciding whether the driver meets the requirements for safe driving or is disqualified. The driver qualification file must contain the MVR and a note showing who performed the review and when.
This isn’t only a CDL issue. Drivers of other covered passenger vehicles, such as vans designed to carry 9 to 15 passengers operated for compensation in interstate commerce, need annual reviews too. And this is separate from the old annual certificate of violations that drivers used to complete. That requirement went away in 2022. The carrier’s responsibility to review the driving record did not.
Our annual review process at a glance
Month 11: Pull the MVR from every state where the driver held a license in the past 12 months.
New activity? Email the assigned contact with what we found and a review form to sign.
Weeks 1–3: One follow-up email a week to the same contact.
Still open? Call the owner while there’s still time to look into the record.
When we pull an MVR, we check the license type and status, medical certification status where applicable, and any endorsements or restrictions. We also look for tickets, violations, or accidents that appear on the record within the past 12 months. Any of that activity triggers an email to the safety manager or the contact the company has assigned to us. We flag what we found and ask the company to look it over and return the signed form. That sign-off is part of our process for handling new activity.
One of the first things I want to know is whether the driver told the company about the incident. An accident entry, for example, tells me something happened. It doesn’t tell me who at the company knew about it or what information they already have. If the driver reported it at the time, the operator can bring that knowledge to the review. If the MVR is the first they’re hearing of it, they have questions of their own to ask. They deserve the chance to ask them before we close out that annual review.
Sometimes the record shows more than a ticket. If an MVR shows a disqualifying offense under § 391.15, the driver can’t operate until the disqualification period ends. If it shows a pattern that concerns the company, the owner has a decision to make. Either way, the decision and the reason for it belong in the driver’s file, alongside the signed review.
When the emails stop and the phone call starts
Our follow-up has a stopping point: we email the assigned contact once a week for three weeks. If those three attempts don’t produce the signed review, we call the owner. That gives the safety manager or company contact time to respond, and it keeps us from spending the rest of the month forwarding the same request to the same inbox. By the third attempt, I know exactly what I need to tell the owner: what showed up, who we contacted, and what we still need from the company.
I’m careful about one distinction on that call. If we haven’t received the form, I can say that. I can’t say nobody looked at the record. Those are two different things, and the answer changes what needs to happen next. If someone completed the review, we need the signed copy back so we can document it and close it out. If nobody has looked at the activity yet, getting someone to sign a piece of paper is only part of the conversation. Somebody still needs to consider what’s on that driver’s record.
Sometimes the call to the owner is what finally gets the signed copy back to us. I also explain what a longer delay can mean. If enough time passes, we may need to pull a fresh MVR, which adds a charge the company could have avoided. Nobody likes paying twice.
The more important issue is the date. The review counts on the day someone actually reviews the record, not the day the MVR was ordered. If that sign-off lands after the 12-month deadline, pulling the record on time doesn’t make the review timely.
What an owner can check
If you own a transportation company, pick one driver whose last annual review showed new activity and ask your team to walk you through it. What did the record show? Who reviewed it, and when? If the person answering can tell you when the MVR was ordered but has to dig through emails to find out whether anyone looked at the accident on it, you’ve found the part of your process that needs attention. Decide who will follow up on an open review and at what point they should bring it to you.
Three emails and a phone call is the approach we use. The useful question for your business is how long an annual review can sit before somebody knows to pick up the phone. I’d much rather call an owner while there’s still time to look into a driver’s record than call after the deadline to explain how many reminders we sent.

